Butler Bay Valley

USD 2,750,000 (1031 Exchanges considered)

This forested 29-acre waterfront property on the NW sunset coast of St. Croix awaits an investor who seeks the privacy and seclusion akin to a small Caribbean island, but with all the advantages of U.S. laws, tax advantages, daily jet service, internet access, U.S. postal system, medical facilities, mainland power, great restaurants and much more.

The Butler Bay valley lies on the verdant sunset coast of St. Croix USVI. Its reasonable comparison to an island is derived from it being a virtually untouched and isolated rain forest valley created by two massive ridgelines that descend from elevations of 600’ to the westward facing shoreline, blocking outside influences. From a security standpoint the Butler Bay Valley can be viewed as a controlled access area. Only a single paved road serves the NW corner of St. Croix, allowing for security monitoring.

The property includes 1800’ of beachfront bordering on vodka clear neon blue waters. One of the best wreck diving sites in the Caribbean lies just offshore and can be seen on YouTube by entering Butler Bay. Due to its remote location and the abundance of beaches elsewhere, Butler Bay beach is seldom used.

The Butler Bay Valley has been virtually untouched since the heyday of West Indies sugar production. Giant specimen trees grow in abundance. White tail deer live in the surrounding nature preserve. Abundant rain and fertile soil produce fast growing guinea grass, excellent for horses etc.

For those who appreciate the ever changing sunsets, they appear nightly directly to the west. For those who are star gazers, with little ambient light, the Milky Way and the Southern Cross seem close. Sea turtles nest on the beach.

The surrounding area is primarily devoted to large undeveloped land holdings. The property to the south with the red roof is the historic Butler Bay Great House circa 1720. Some of the surrounding properties may be available if needed.

Butler Bay Valley

This forested 29-acre waterfront property on the NW sunset coast of St. Croix awaits an investor who seeks the privacy and seclusion akin to a small Caribbean island, but with all the advantages of U.S. laws, tax advantages, daily jet service, internet access, U.S. postal system, medical facilities, mainland power, great restaurants and much more.

The Butler Bay valley lies on the verdant sunset coast of St. Croix USVI. Its reasonable comparison to an island is derived from it being a virtually untouched and isolated rain forest valley created by two massive ridgelines that descend from elevations of 600’ to the westward facing shoreline, blocking outside influences. From a security standpoint the Butler Bay Valley can be viewed as a controlled access area. Only a single paved road serves the NW corner of St. Croix, allowing for security monitoring.

The property includes 1800’ of beachfront bordering on vodka clear neon blue waters. One of the best wreck diving sites in the Caribbean lies just offshore and can be seen on YouTube by entering Butler Bay. Due to its remote location and the abundance of beaches elsewhere, Butler Bay beach is seldom used.

The Butler Bay Valley has been virtually untouched since the heyday of West Indies sugar production. Giant specimen trees grow in abundance. White tail deer live in the surrounding nature preserve. Abundant rain and fertile soil produce fast growing guinea grass, excellent for horses etc.

For those who appreciate the ever changing sunsets, they appear nightly directly to the west. For those who are star gazers, with little ambient light, the Milky Way and the Southern Cross seem close. Sea turtles nest on the beach.

The surrounding area is primarily devoted to large undeveloped land holdings. The property to the south with the red roof is the historic Butler Bay Great House circa 1720. Some of the surrounding properties may be available if needed.

USD 2,750,000 (1031 Exchanges considered)
29.10 Acres
Freehold
Island Parcel
Non Developed
Location: Estate Prospect Hill – NW corner St. Croix

Butler Bay Valley

USD 2,750,000 (1031 Exchanges considered)

17°44'59.8"N, 64°53'27.0"W
29 Acres
USD 2,750,000 (1031 Exchanges considered)
Island Parcel
Non Developed
Freehold

Butler Bay Valley

USD 2,750,000 (1031 Exchanges considered)

ajax-loader

EXCLUSIVE PRIVATE ISLANDS

Your Personal Private Island Playground. Experience the whole island for just one group at a time. Stunning locations, ultra private and all Inclusive. Curated by Private Islands Inc.

VIEW OUR COLLECTION

A site membership also gives you full access to all locked listings.

Sign up now!

Join our exclusive Private Islands community of over 100,000 subscribers and unlock access to a world of breathtaking island properties. Delivered straight to your inbox monthly. Be among the first to discover the latest listings, insider tips, and exclusive offers tailored for island enthusiasts.

Own it, Live it, Experience it