Middle Cay

Overview: Enjoy the exclusive private island experience while taking advantage of nearby Harbour Island amenities! Middle Cay is a luxurious, private island just off the coast of Harbour Island. With a coconut tree grove, two villas, and daily housekeeping, this two-acre island combines five-star amenities with a secluded location for the ultimate Caribbean getaway.

Unique Features:

  • Two Villas: The Main House and the Cottage, both equipped with modern amenities including WiFi and air-conditioning.

  • Water Activities: Fishing gear, a canoe, standup paddle board, and three kayaks. The surrounding islands are known for their pink sand beaches, coral reefs, and shipwrecks.

  • Scenic Walkway and Fire Pit: A walkway winds around the entire island, perfect for evening strolls, and a fire pit for making s'mores.

Location:

  • Harbour Island, Bahamas

  • Just off the coast, easily accessible by boat.

Accessibility:

  • Boat Transfer: Guests can enjoy a 2-minute boat ride from the nearest dock.

  • Nearby Amenities: Harbour Island offers jet ski, boat, bicycle, and golf cart rentals, as well as several restaurants and beaches.

Accommodations:

  • Main House:

    • Features: Open kitchen and dining space with stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and a dining table that seats 8. Living room with a flatscreen cable TV, private patio, heated pool, and outdoor shower.

    • Bedrooms: Four bedrooms including a spacious master suite with a king bed, ocean views, private patio, lounge, and ensuite bathroom. Additional suites with double beds, twin beds, and king bed, each with ensuite or hall bathrooms.

  • Cottage:

    • Features: Common area with exposed wooden beams, tile floors, plush furnishings, flatscreen cable TV, and ocean views. Kitchen with stainless steel appliances, coffeemaker, and mixer.

    • Bedrooms: Three bedrooms including a king suite with ocean views and ensuite bathroom, a suite with double beds and ensuite bathroom, and a children's suite with a twin bunk, trundle bed, and half bath.

Why You Should Choose Middle Cay:

  • Exclusive Privacy: A secluded retreat with luxurious amenities and no neighboring properties.

  • Luxurious Accommodations: Modern villas with all the comforts of home.

  • Water Adventures: Perfect for boating enthusiasts and water sports lovers.

  • Scenic Beauty: Stunning views, a lighthouse, and a fire pit for cozy evenings.

Additional Information:

  • Boat: Included in all rentals at all times. Boat captain included for 7 consecutive hours, after which the rate is $35 per hour for the captain. Fuel and oil are not included.

  • Complimentary Activities: For week-long stays, guests can choose two complimentary 4-hour activities, such as water tubing, water skiing, feeding the pigs in Meeks Patch, underwater diving with a Yamaha Sea Scooter, or touring nearby islands.

Middle Cay

Overview: Enjoy the exclusive private island experience while taking advantage of nearby Harbour Island amenities! Middle Cay is a luxurious, private island just off the coast of Harbour Island. With a coconut tree grove, two villas, and daily housekeeping, this two-acre island combines five-star amenities with a secluded location for the ultimate Caribbean getaway.

Unique Features:

  • Two Villas: The Main House and the Cottage, both equipped with modern amenities including WiFi and air-conditioning.

  • Water Activities: Fishing gear, a canoe, standup paddle board, and three kayaks. The surrounding islands are known for their pink sand beaches, coral reefs, and shipwrecks.

  • Scenic Walkway and Fire Pit: A walkway winds around the entire island, perfect for evening strolls, and a fire pit for making s'mores.

Location:

  • Harbour Island, Bahamas

  • Just off the coast, easily accessible by boat.

Accessibility:

  • Boat Transfer: Guests can enjoy a 2-minute boat ride from the nearest dock.

  • Nearby Amenities: Harbour Island offers jet ski, boat, bicycle, and golf cart rentals, as well as several restaurants and beaches.

Accommodations:

  • Main House:

    • Features: Open kitchen and dining space with stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and a dining table that seats 8. Living room with a flatscreen cable TV, private patio, heated pool, and outdoor shower.

    • Bedrooms: Four bedrooms including a spacious master suite with a king bed, ocean views, private patio, lounge, and ensuite bathroom. Additional suites with double beds, twin beds, and king bed, each with ensuite or hall bathrooms.

  • Cottage:

    • Features: Common area with exposed wooden beams, tile floors, plush furnishings, flatscreen cable TV, and ocean views. Kitchen with stainless steel appliances, coffeemaker, and mixer.

    • Bedrooms: Three bedrooms including a king suite with ocean views and ensuite bathroom, a suite with double beds and ensuite bathroom, and a children's suite with a twin bunk, trundle bed, and half bath.

Why You Should Choose Middle Cay:

  • Exclusive Privacy: A secluded retreat with luxurious amenities and no neighboring properties.

  • Luxurious Accommodations: Modern villas with all the comforts of home.

  • Water Adventures: Perfect for boating enthusiasts and water sports lovers.

  • Scenic Beauty: Stunning views, a lighthouse, and a fire pit for cozy evenings.

Additional Information:

  • Boat: Included in all rentals at all times. Boat captain included for 7 consecutive hours, after which the rate is $35 per hour for the captain. Fuel and oil are not included.

  • Complimentary Activities: For week-long stays, guests can choose two complimentary 4-hour activities, such as water tubing, water skiing, feeding the pigs in Meeks Patch, underwater diving with a Yamaha Sea Scooter, or touring nearby islands.

Whole Island: $$$$
Self Service
Location: Just off the coast of Harbour Island, Bahamas

Middle Cay

Whole Island $$$$

25°30'4.3"N, 76°38'31.3"W
Location:: Eleuthera , Bahamas , Caribbean
0 Acres
$$$$
Self Service

Middle Cay

Whole Island $$$$

ajax-loader

EXCLUSIVE PRIVATE ISLANDS

Your Personal Private Island Playground. Experience the whole island for just one group at a time. Stunning locations, ultra private and all Inclusive. Curated by Private Islands Inc.

VIEW OUR COLLECTION

A site membership also gives you full access to all locked listings.

Sign up now!

Join our exclusive Private Islands community of over 100,000 subscribers and unlock access to a world of breathtaking island properties. Delivered straight to your inbox monthly. Be among the first to discover the latest listings, insider tips, and exclusive offers tailored for island enthusiasts.

Own it, Live it, Experience it